CarrieAnn Sudlow vs Charle
Side-by-side comparison of two UK SEO and AI search agencies on price, contract length, AI platform coverage, sector specialism, and verdict.
CarrieAnn Sudlow (from £1,500/month, 3-month minimum, 4 AI platforms covered) is best for founder-led saas and b2b brands wanting hands-on consultant access. Charle (from £3,000/month, 6-month minimum, 4 AI platforms covered) is best for shopify and ecommerce brands wanting ai search + technical seo together. Pick CarrieAnn Sudlow if you prioritise saas or b2b; pick Charle if you prioritise ecommerce or shopify plus.
Side-by-side
| Criterion | CarrieAnn Sudlow | Charle |
|---|---|---|
| Headquarters | Manchester, UK | London, UK |
| Founded | 2018 | 2014 |
| Team size | 1-5 | 20-50 |
| Starting price | £1,500/mo · cheaper | £3,000/mo |
| Pricing band | Boutique consultant | Mid-market |
| Minimum contract | 3 months · shorter | 6 months |
| Services | AI SEO, GEO, Consultancy | AI SEO, GEO, Shopify, Ecommerce SEO |
| Sector focus | SaaS, B2B, Service businesses | Ecommerce, Shopify Plus, DTC |
| AI platforms covered | ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, AI Overviews (4) | ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, AI Overviews (4) |
| Proprietary tool | — | — |
| Case studies | 5-10 | 10+ |
| Best for | Founder-led SaaS and B2B brands wanting hands-on consultant access | Shopify and ecommerce brands wanting AI search + technical SEO together |
| Watch out for | Single-consultant capacity caps execution volume; no team cover | Ecommerce focus may not fit B2B service businesses |
When CarrieAnn Sudlow wins
Pick CarrieAnn Sudlow if your business matches the saas or b2b or service businesses profile, your monthly budget is comfortable around £1,500, and you want 3 disciplines from one provider. Their 3-month minimum contract suits brands willing to commit but unwilling to lock in for a year.
When Charle wins
Pick Charle if your business matches the ecommerce or shopify plus or dtc profile, your monthly budget is comfortable around £3,000, and you want 4 disciplines from one provider. Their 6-month minimum contract suits brands willing to commit but unwilling to lock in for a year.
Verdict
Neither agency is universally better. The right answer depends on your sector, budget, and AI platform priorities. If you want a third independent option to consider alongside this comparison, use the SEOCompare agency matcher to surface a personalised three-to-five-agency shortlist.
Not sure which to choose?
Get a free AI visibility audit to benchmark your current performance, then brief whichever agency fits.
Request your free audit